Showing posts with label election. Show all posts
Showing posts with label election. Show all posts

Saturday, September 20, 2008

Poll Details and Observations: CBS / NY Times Poll of September 17, 2008

As we head into the stretch of the 2008 presidential race, we are bombarded with poll results on a daily basis. But usually we only see the “bottom line” numbers: what percentage of voters as a whole favor each candidate. These are obviously the most important figures, but while they tell us the general state of the race, they don’t provide much information about each candidates’ strengths and weaknesses, and where their messages are penetrating or being rejected.

To get the more detailed and useful information in polls, it is necessary to go beyond the bottom line and number and look into the poll internals. The two most important internals are the answers to specific questions about the candidate, and crosstabs, which show how answers to questions break down by political affiliation, gender, race and other factors.

Since I am always curious about what’s going on behind the scenes, I’ve decided I will regularly dig into poll internals and report my observations. Polling firms vary greatly in terms of whether or not they release their internals. Some do not, and others do only for subscribers, but some provide full information for their polls. One of these is the CBS / NY Times poll, which has a large number of questions and answers.

I’ve decided to use the CBS/NYT September 17th poll (based on polling done from Sept 12-16) for this analysis. This poll shows Obama leading McCain 48%-43% among registered voters, and 49%-44% among likely voters.

Note that while I am obviously partisan in this election, I do make an effort to be objective in my observations in this sort of analysis.


Here are some of the more noteworthy items I found in this poll’s internals.

1. The biggest swing in overall support between this poll and the one taken on September 8 was in independent voters: they had previously been 55-29 in McCain’s favor, but are now 46-41 for Obama. Frankly, this strikes me as an excessively large shift and makes me suspect that something is off a bit here. Also a bit strange is Democrat support for McCain increasing from 6% to 10%, though this could just be noise.

2. Both McCain and Obama are seen as bringing change to Washington in larger numbers than they were a month ago, but Obama continues to hold a huge lead in this area: 65% to 37%. Among independents the numbers are similar: 61%-35%.

3. On “maverickness”, Obama actually does better than McCain. He is seen as a “different type of Democrat” by 47%, whereas 48% see him as “typical”; McCain’s figures are 40% and 57% respectively. Note that Kerry’s scores were 30% and 55% in July 2004, likely one of many important reasons why Kerry lost.

4. Obama continues to consistently lead in the “soft” appeal type questions, such as who can you relate to and who understands voters’ needs and problems. On the latter question he trounces McCain 60%-33%, which is a bit surprising. McCain has actually lost ground in this area.

5. Conversely, McCain continues to beat Obama soundly in his strong suit areas: experience and military leadership. A plurality of voters now believe Obama is prepared to be president, but only barely: 48% to 46%. He has a lot more work to do in this area. Only 26% feel that Obama would be very likely to be an effective commander-in-chief, while 52% feel McCain would. Obama is not making any headway in this area, and it’s a serious weakness for him.

6. Much has been made about how Sarah Palin increased enthusiasm among McCain voters, and it is true that he has improved in this area, but he still trails Obama by a large margin. 61% of Obama supporters are enthusiastic, while 23% have reservations (difference of 38%); McCain’s figures are 47% and 37% (difference of 10%).

7. The “McCain is out of touch” meme seems to be succeeding with independent voters, but the “McCain is not a plain talker” meme is not nearly as effective; in fact, Obama scores worse on this than McCain. Independents say Obama understands their needs and problems by a 57%-35% margin, but McCain scores just 48%-45%. Asked if he says what he believes or not, independents rate McCain 58%-38% but Obama gets an anemic 47%-49%.

8. Many people have tried to claim that Obama’s effort to tie McCain to Bush is not effective: the numbers suggest otherwise. A full 46% believe McCain would continue Bush policies (up from 42% in a prior poll), including 38% of independents.

9. On VP picks, voters see McCain’s pick of Sarah Palin clearly: a whopping 75% of them said he chose her to try to win the election, and only 17% because she’s well qualified. Biden’s scores are 57% for qualifications and 31% to help Obama win.

10. In terms of readiness to serve as president, 65% say Biden would be and 24% say he would not. But for Palin, the numbers are 33% “qualified” and 62% “concerned”. This may be part of why Obama has regained some of his lead. Even 32% of McCain supporters are concerned about Palin. The Alaskan governor is now considered by 42% to be prepared to be VP while 52% say she is not; an earlier September poll had 47% saying prepared and 42% unprepared – a bad trend for McCain.

11. Biden’s net favorability is +21% with a high 45% undecided; this is largely unchanged since he was picked. Palin has a net +10% with 30% undecided, down from +22% in a September 8 poll. Independents still have a +14% favorability rating of Palin, which is better news for McCain.

12. If McCain intended the Palin pick to appeal to Hillary Clinton voters, he failed miserably (no surprise to me or most other observers, of course). Palin’s net favorability among former Clinton supporters is a whopping -28% (20% pro, 48% against). Despite this, though, 25% of former Clinton supporters say they will back McCain, which of course is a problem for Obama.

13. Another interesting but unsurprising observation: 2% of McCain supporters said they were “angry” about Obama’s selection of Joe Biden; 20% of Obama supporters said this about McCain’s choice of Sarah Palin.

14. So far, at least, Palin is not being penalized very much by voters for allegations of misconduct as governor or claims about her honesty – very few voters state these as reasons for disliking her.

15. Palin is seen as someone voters can relate to by a 55% to 42% margin; this is down from 60%-34% in a prior poll.

16. A near majority (48%) of Americans rate the economy and jobs as the most important election issue, including 58% of Democrats, 41% of Republicans and 40% of independents. Voters have confidence in Obama to deal with the economy by a 60%-39% margin; for McCain the figures are 53%-46%.

17. Neither candidate is having much luck convincing Americans that their taxes will go down if he’s elected, but Obama is failing miserably on this count. 34% of Americans think McCain will raise their taxes, but 49% think Obama will. Conversely, 15% think Obama will lower their taxes, and just 8% feel this about McCain. Obama does much worse here among independents than McCain: 53% think Obama will raise taxes and 12% lower them, compared to 31%-13% scores for McCain. This may well be Obama’s single biggest failure to communicate of the election (or McCain’s greatest success).

18. On Iraq, 26% are very confident of Obama’s ability to handle the situation and 26% somewhat confident; for McCain the figures are 36% and 20% respectively. Americans want the war ended within a year or two as opposed to staying longer by a 59%-37% margin.

19. 62% of Republicans approve of the job George W. Bush is doing? Really? Um. Wow.

Monday, September 8, 2008

Don't Panic - 10 Reasons Why Obama Supporters Should Chill

After the Democratic National Convention, the mood was exultant among Democrats and others who want to see Barack Obama win the election. The convention did well to unite Democrats, and Obama capped it off with a rousing speech before a huge crowd. He got a boost in the polls, and his supporters felt confident.

Then came John McCain’s announcement of the Sarah Palin pick, followed by the Republican National Convention. Democrats got to see that Republicans, too, can get excited and energized. McCain whittled away at Obama’s lead in the national tracking polls, and has now even pulled ahead in a couple of them.

Democrats are starting to get worried. No, actually, some have gone well beyond that – they are freaking out. I hear the same refrains in so many quarters: Why is Obama behind McCain? Has the election changed with the Palin pick? Why isn’t Obama winning easily in this Democrat-favored race? Is his message not getting across? Why is he so soft on the opposition, instead of fighting back? Why don’t we counter the McCain attack ads with some of our own? We need to do something!!

Indeed, we do. We need to calm down.


Unrealistic Expectations

First of all, some Democrats seriously need a dose of reality in terms of how they thought this election would play out. Too many thought it would be a cakewalk, because they had an exciting new, young candidate and the national mood was sour on Bush and the Republicans. How could they lose with such an inspiring leader, in a country yearning for change?

The answer is simple: not everyone wants change, and even among those who want it, some don’t trust Obama to deliver it. Obama himself knows this – he’s said from the start that this would not be a landslide, it would be a tough, close campaign. And as in so many other cases, he’s proven that he knows what he’s talking about.

Polls are glimpses into the state of the election, so it is natural to worry when they seem to turn against you. And it’s also perfectly normal, when you feel attacked, to want to respond with attacks of your own. But let me remind you that this sort of emotional “we need to do something” attitude in response to an attack is a big part of what got us into the morass known as the Iraq War. How well did that work out?

In that context, let me give you ten reasons why you should chill out and not worry so much about the polls and all the other daily ups and downs and noise.


1. National Tracking Polls are Deceptive

Organizations like Gallup put out daily polls purporting to show the state of the race, but these are tracking polls conducted on a nation-wide basis. Our election is not a simple popular vote taken across the country – it is based on state-by-state contests. While movements in national tracking polls certainly matter, being behind in one of these polls doesn’t necessarily mean the one trailing is losing the election.

Consider the Palin pick and the response to it. While certainly the McCain ticket has benefited nationally, does that mean it has actually moved any states? We don’t know yet, as there have been no state polls since the conventions. Remember: it doesn’t matter if Palin energizes a bunch of hard-right conservatives so that McCain wins a state like Texas by 20 points instead of 10: the number of electoral college votes is identical. All that really matters is the swing states.


2. Convention Bounces are Normal and Expected

Most candidates get a noticeable “bounce” in the polls after their conventions: Obama got one a week ago and McCain is getting his now. Why does this happen? Simple: each convention allows one candidate to get a huge amount of free propaganda time without rebuttal from his or her opponent. This happens in almost every year.

The fact that McCain moved ahead of Obama after his convention doesn’t mean Obama is in trouble. If McCain had not moved ahead of Obama, that would have meant McCain was in trouble.

This year, matters are even more complicated, because the conventions were back-to-back. All of the polling data is suspect until enough time elapses for the bounces to settle down.


3. Bounces Fade

Remember when Obama went on his “magical mystery tour” to Europe and the Middle East? He shot out to a 49%-40% lead over McCain in the Gallup tracking poll on July 27th. But by July 31st, just four days later, the race was back to 45%-44%.

Consider this graphic from Gallup during the 2004 election, showing the situation in late September:

(Source: Gallup.com)

Looks pretty bad for Kerry, doesn’t it? Bush moved out to a 13-point lead and even two weeks after his convention, Bush was still up by 8.

Now, here’s the same poll two weeks later:

(Source: Gallup.com)

That's Kerry who was up 49%-48% there, by the way. Yes, Kerry eventually lost, but by a small margin. Trailing in the polls by big numbers in September didn’t matter – it was just noise.


4. Sarah Palin is the “Flavor of the Week”

McCain and the Republicans seem to think they’ve scored a home run with the Sarah Palin pick. She’s excited “the base” and gotten a lot of attention. She’s all over the media: she’s being discussed on talk shows, she’s the focus of political pundits, and will soon be splashed all over the supermarket checkout aisle as well.

Does this strike you as ironic coming from a guy who made an issue of Obama’s “celebrity” all summer? Indeed, but remember that this also means that McCain and Palin get the flipside. Remember when Obama started to receive criticism for getting too much media exposure and voters started to experience “Obama burnout”? The exact same thing will happen here.

Sarah Palin is the media darling right now, but that never lasts. The more popular she gets, the more people will expect her to give honest answers about her many scandals and problems. And eventually, the short attention span of Americans will turn to something more interesting, the Palin circus will fold up its Big Top, and then we’ll be back to more important matters: the issues that John McCain thinks voters don’t care about.


5. This is the Fifth Inning, not the Ninth

Some people seem to forget that we are barely a week past Labor Day, not approaching Halloween. The bulk of the campaign is still ahead of us, including all of the debates. Simply put, not enough has happened yet to start worrying that either Obama is “in trouble” or “running out of time”.


6. Obama’s Campaign Approach Works

Obama has built up his candidacy and his campaign from scratch with a new approach unlike any other in recent American history. It is based on a focus on the issues, a high road respect for the opposition, and a relentless message that the election should be about helping the American people deal with serious problems, not about who was a POW 40 years ago or who can skin a moose.

It might be satisfying to think of Obama going to town on McCain and Palin and ripping them to shreds, but it would probably be a big mistake. It would undercut his entire message and it would reek of desperation. And what’s worse, it wouldn’t likely help him a bit.

The McCain/Palin ticket is trying to ignite a culture war of right versus left, rural versus urban, and yes, to some extent, white versus black. After 18 months of a noble, issue-focused campaign, Obama cannot expect that he can now jump into the pig sty and beat the pigs at their own game. It won’t work because it’s not how he operates.

He needs to stay on message, as he has all along: this is not about right versus left, it’s about the future and what’s best for American families.


7. Presidential Campaigns are Like Icebergs

As voters, our information is extremely limited: we only see the part of the iceberg above the water line. The campaigns themselves know much, much more about what is really going on at the ground level, and on a state by state basis, because they have their own networks, internal polling and other data we never see. For example, when McCain picked Palin he surprised a lot of people because at that time the race seemed very close. It is widely theorized that he made his “Hail Mary” pass because his own people knew things were going far worse than it appeared on the surface.

I don’t believe in blind faith, but I do have faith that if the sun rose in the east every day until now, it probably will tomorrow as well. Remember that a year ago, people considered Hillary Clinton so much a shoo-in for the Democratic nod that people mused that she was practically an incumbent. Millions laughed at the notion that the skinny black kid from Chicago could tackle the Clinton Machine and win. They aren’t laughing now.

So while I understand and share some of your concerns over Obama’s relatively “soft” approach, his team has earned some benefit of the doubt.


8. Obama’s “Ground Game” is Unprecedented

One key aspect of the “iceberg” issue is that we see polls and ads and stories in the media, but we do not see the “ground game”. This term refers to state-based field offices, volunteer forces and other efforts to register new voters, keep enthusiasm high, and encourage them to actually get out and vote on November 4th.

Obama’s people have made this part of the campaign a huge priority, because this is what it is really all about: votes. Consider some recent figures from the Swing State Project, showing the following changes in voter registration in some key states:

  • Colorado: Went from a 165,423 registration advantage for Republicans in 2006, to only 78,227 so far in 2008.
  • Florida: From a 283,856 Democratic advantage to a 465,617 advantage.
  • Iowa: From an 18,195 Democratic advantage to a 99,014 advantage.
  • Nevada: From 15,309 Democratic to 76,053.
  • Pennsylvania: From 599,791 Democratic to 1,111,900!
These are huge, huge numbers and if there's a campaign that's worried about them, it's probably not Obama's.


9. Invisible Voters Don’t Get Polled

Continuing again on the “iceberg” theme, remember that polls are based on statistical models that project what will happen in this election from what has happened in prior years. By their very nature, then, they tend to lag behind and be unresponsive to new trends.

Consider some of the areas where Obama is running huge leads over McCain: young people, Internet users, urban professionals who use cell phones, new immigrants, and all those new voters I mentioned just above. These are all historically under-represented in polls.


10. Campaigns Hold Good Stuff Back

An important part of a good campaign is timing: you have to play your cards when they will have the most effect. You don’t just throw everything you have out there at once, because it all gets jumbled together and it fades from public view too quickly.

As just one example, it is widely theorized that General Colin Powell may – note that word please – endorse Barack Obama. If true, Obama will ask Powell to wait to make that announcement at a time when it will be of maximum benefit to his campaign.

Similarly, by not panicking now, Obama also holds in reserve any potential “Hail Mary” pass of his own. Obama is principled, but he’s no fool, and the Democratic leadership knows what’s at stake here. If Obama really does get to the point where he feels like he is going to lose, he can shake things up any time from now until shortly before the election – there’s no rush.

--

Chill Out

I hope this article has made you feel a bit better about the current state of affairs. If you’re still worried, don’t sit around biting your fingernails to a stump – do something productive! Send a donation, volunteer to make some phone calls, or heck, start a blog. Anything constructive you do will not only help you achieve what you want – an Obama/Biden victory in November – it will make you feel much better at the same time.

Keep your wits about you, folks – there’s still a long road ahead of us, and much work to be done.